It was just a matter of time, wasn’t it? With domestic remittance services launching left right and centre, EcoCash was the last marquee name that wasn’t in the mix. Which was, until last night, a little surprising…
The remittance game in Zimbabwe is one of the most sought after because the figures for incoming funds have been increasing over the last couple of years even when early pandemic projections had them going down in Sub-Saharan Africa.
In 2021 the figure for Zimbabwe stood at US$1.430 billion which was a 43% increase from the sum registered in 2020 and the year of the pandemic saw remittances hit a billion which surpassed the then all-time high of US$939 million recorded in 2015.
With the numbers continually on an upward trend, companies have tried to position themselves wherever they can to make the most out of cash inflows. We saw a lot of activity from banks like CBZ launching a dedicated money transfer branch, to remittance startups like Senditoo and Shumba Money offering limited run transaction free promotions for cash sent to Zimbabwe.
On the domestic front, businesses have also tried to find out where they fit into this and we have seen a number of domestic remittance services like BancABC’s City Hopper, NBS Banks’s Instant Cash, Steward Bank Remit, Mojo Mula and many others. Even mobile money operator OneMoney launched its own service (OneRemit) to try and muscle in on local foreign currency trade. And now the country’s largest mobile money service EcoCash has thrown its hat in the ring.
EcoCash domestic remittances
Last night EcoCash Zimbabwe announced that it would be entering the domestic remittance game through its EcoCash FCA wallet. The mobile money operator said that customers will be able to do this through a new shortcode, *153#.
This new access platform is there to give some separation from the conventional EcoCash *151# which is for local currency only. And for those who prefer using the EcoCash app, the service is there but you will be able to switch between local currency and USD.
Limits, cash-in/cash-out, and charges charges charges
The service is open for everyone even if you aren’t a registered EcoCash customer. However, there are some differences in how much you’ll be able to send. If you are a registered EcoCash customer, you will be able to send US$500 per week with a limit of US$2,000 per month with those who are unregistered only getting to send half that amount. This is not out of the ordinary because those are similar terms to BancABC’s City Hopper.
As with any other remittance service, you will be able to cash in and out at the Econet Shops nationwide or you can cash in and send the money through your FCA Wallet. To make a transfer in person, you will, of course, need to bring with you your ID/Driver’s Licence/Valid Passport and the money you wish to transfer.
The next question is “How much is this all going to cost?” and the answer to that question is:
| BANDS | REGISTERED CUSTOMERS | UNREGISTERED CUSTOMERS | ||
| Lower Value (S) | Upper Value (S) | Send Money Fees | Cash Out Tariff | Send Money Tariff |
| 1.00 | 1.99 | 0.06 | 0.03 | 0.09 |
| 2.00 | (5.00 | 0.07 | 0.17 | 0,36 |
| 5.01 | 10.00 | 0.16 | 0.26 | 0.58 |
| 10.01 | 20.00 | 0.32 | 0,52 | 1.14 |
| 20.01 | 30.00 | 0.48 | 0.78 | 1.71 |
| 30.01 | 40.00 | 0.61 | 1.04 | 2.30 |
| 40.01 | 50.00 | 0.78 | 1.30 | 2.88 |
| 50.01 | 60.00 | 1.11 | 1.74 | 3.91 |
| 60.01 | 75.00 | 1.15 | 2.00 | 4.41 |
| 75.01 | 100.00 | 1.56 | 2.61 | 5.79 |
| 100.01 | 150.00 | 1.96 | 3.04 | 6.86 |
| 150.01 | 200.00 | 2.30 | 3.39 | 7.74 |
| 200.01 | 300.00 | 2.68 | 4.82 | 9.84 |
| 300.01 | 400.00 | 3.73 | 6.77 | 13.43 |
| 400.01 | 500.00 | 4.78 | 8.72 | 17.30 |
From the tariff table, EcoCash’s domestic remittance service looks to be the cheapest in Zimbabwe when you are going up to the higher figures (for just sending money, it’s complicated but I’ll explain). For example, if you want to send US$100 (as a registered customer) you will be charged 1.56% which is cheaper in comparison to the competition because for the same amount you will be charged:
| Limit | Fees | Cost of sending US$100 | |
| BancABC City Hopper | US$250 for non-BancABC customers US$500 for BancABC customers | 3% | US$3.00 |
| Access Forex | – | 3% | US$3.00 |
| Mukuru | US$1000 | 7% | US$7.00 |
| NBS InstaCash | – | 3% | US$3.00 |
| Steward Remit | – | 2% | US$2.00 |
| MojoMula | – | 5% | US$5.00 |
However, on the receiving end if you choose to cash out the money you will be charged US$2.61 for the US$100 you have received. So, if for example, you owe someone the US$100, you’ll have to factor in the cost of sending the money US$1.56 as well as the US$2.61 if they intend on cashing out. The fees, according to the launch event, are factoring in the 2% tax that the govt instated on all transactions.
Pricey, are there any benefits?
Those fees are a little steep in comparison to what is offered on the market, however, there are some benefits when dealing with a wallet-based remittance service. The first that I can think of is you can deposit the money into your EcoCash FCA in bulk (which is a default account if you are registered on EcoCash). All you’ll then have to do is send the money from your EcoCash FCA to your intended recipient or multiple people.
This might help in cutting travel costs and wait times at Econet shops if you were to do it transaction by transaction as you would with any other domestic remittance service that doesn’t have a wallet.
The second advantage is that this kinda solves the change issue that we have all encountered when transacting in USD. Zimbabwean companies love to price things in dollars and cents but can’t give you the exact change. This usually forces many to receive the remainder in local currency at whatever rate the seller is feeling on that day. And it’s rare for someone selling something to afford you a favourable rate. They will most often like to profit whatever they can from the transaction or the sale doesn’t go ahead if the buyer decides to pull out.
Additionally, if the money was meant for a specific service that requires USD then paying it out of a wallet digitally might be a better option, especially on days when that service doesn’t have an open branch.
The third benefit, which is more for EcoCash, is that customers stay within the Econet Group ecosystem. Yesterday we reported on the Econet Smart USD bundles, which are one of many services/merchants that the mobile money operator’s customers can use their EcoCash FCA wallet to pay.
These are just a few things that I could think of that might make these charges worth it. However, I would really like to know what you think about EcoCash’s domestic remittance service.
Almost forgot
At the launch event last night, EcoCash also said that it was doing a dollar for dollar promotion which will see EcoCash matching whatever you send through their domestic remittance system up to US$10.
The mobile money operator has set aside US$10,000 for this so it appears that if you put in US$10, EcoCash will credit you with the equivalent amount.
Share
Home
17 comments
Finally. Soooo happy
Like your tech news guys. Great job. The FCA wallet will be a game changer and allow us to get back to the old days. I just hope it will not be abused.
Passion Java aripi atiudze kuti rino igore reEconet
A real game changer which will bring the convenience of paying for items to the US cent. I hope, as happened before, no spanner will be thrown into the US dollar wallet!
Its cheaper to send with Inbucks since cash out is free
Thanks for covering this and a comparison with what’s on the market.
Please do a piece on how all these services stack up against Innbucks. Innscor/Simbisa appear to be making massive progress in the space. One could argue they’re better positioned than banks because of a very elaborate agent network through their fast food outlets.
When will the Post Office jump in on this? Or even Telecel which needs all the revenue streams it can get ?
Fancy meeting you in the comments Nigel 😁
Yeah, great piece from Valentine that brings to the fore what’s in the market. Would have been great if Innbucks were added to the mix as a comparison.
Innbucks have definitely taken advantage of the absence of Ecocash in this space and really penetrated the market. I say this not only as an active user, but also from the many WhatsApp groups that I’m in.
While the fight may be on pricing for now (Innbucks is currently in the lead on that, their 2% total cost – charged to sender and not the recipient) at a certain stage factors cush as maximum send amount (Innbucks behind as they’re limited to US$200 currently) , easy of transacting (are there system down times), liquidity (is a client always able to withdraw what they need to as and when they need to) and location points (how far does a client need to travel in order to deposit/withdraw).
I’d think whomever can win on these fronts the quickest will win the day..
Techzim pieces on Econet sound like sponsored content. Advantages of higher charges? Like seriously? Compare with Innbucks
Your articles on Econet and it’s subsidiaries seem to be biased. Have you done comparisons with other domestic remittances agencies to conclude that Ecocash is cheaper and convenient. We have been here before with cash in and cash out services from Ecocash which were later abused by their agents who would charge premiums of between 20 to 50 percent just to cash out your money until the government intervened and banned agent services. Their Ecocash system is partly the reason why the black market rate spiralled out of control as it became a conduit for foreign currency dealers to fleece the public of their hard earned cash in the process getting filthy rich overnight.
That is a fair point. What needs to be done is to put in place and enforce safe guards that ensure this does not happen. EcoCash needs to learn and act on this.
Good move especially for the buying of smart bundles but for domestic money transfers will stick to innbucks very cheap
Cab I pay online using this
How much are the charges for making online payments using the ecocash usd wallet? For example making a dstv payment.
Thanks for sharing this comparission of usd money transfers with a domestic remittance service.
This is way more cheaper than other remittance agencies.
This is way more cheaper than other remittance agencies.
This is not cheaper at all especially when you are senting large amounts i just got out of an econet shop right now there is a 4% gvt tax added charged to both the sender and recipient which is not included on those charges above